New York – October 28, 2026
The Center for Environmental and Social Development (CESD) is following with grave concern the security and military developments between the Syrian Arab Republic and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, following the armed attack that targeted a Greek Orthodox church in Jordan’s Karak Governorate on October 23, 2026, and the subsequent Jordanian airstrikes on areas in southern Syria, which human rights and media reports say resulted in the deaths of at least seven civilians, including children and women.
While reiterating its condemnation of all forms of violence, terrorism, and attacks on civilians and places of worship, the Center affirms that protecting national security and combating terrorism do not exempt any state from its obligations under international law, nor do they grant it unlimited authority to use military force beyond its borders or to put civilian lives at risk.
First: The Right to Life and the Protection of the Civilian Population
The Center affirms that the right to life is an inherent and non-derogable right, in accordance with Article (6) of the 1966 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and Article (3) of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In situations in which international humanitarian law applies, parties are bound by the principles of distinction, proportionality, and precautions during attacks, in accordance with the relevant rules of customary international law, particularly:
Rule (1): The obligation to distinguish between civilians and combatants.
Rule (7): The obligation to distinguish between civilian objects and military objectives.
Rule (14): The prohibition of attacks expected to cause incidental civilian harm that would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated.
Rule (15): The obligation to take all feasible precautions to avoid or minimize civilian losses.
The Center stresses that these principles apply whenever international humanitarian law applies, irrespective of the security or political justifications offered for the military operation.
Second: Respect for National Sovereignty and Constraints on the Use of Force
The Center affirms that Article (2/4) of the United Nations Charter prohibits the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of states, subject to exceptions permitted under international law, particularly the right of self-defense in accordance with Article (51) of the Charter. Article (2/3) of the Charter also obliges states to settle their international disputes by peaceful means. Accordingly, the Center calls on the Jordanian government and the Syrian interim government to clarify the legal basis for cross-border military operations, the nature of the threats on which military decisions were based, and whether those operations were conducted with prior consent or under joint security arrangements. Combating terrorism should not become an additional source of violence or a justification for circumventing the rules of international law governing the use of force and the protection of civilians.
Third: Transparency and Disclosure of Security Agreements and Understandings
The Center expresses concern about conflicting official statements regarding security coordination between Damascus and Amman, and the lack of sufficient information on the understandings and mechanisms governing military and security operations that directly affect the civilian population. Article (102) of the United Nations Charter establishes the principle of registering and publishing international treaties and agreements, thereby enhancing transparency in relations between states and limiting secret diplomacy.
In this context, the Center calls on both governments to announce the legal and institutional frameworks governing their security cooperation, clarify the nature of any binding agreements, if they exist, and disclose the principles and safeguards governing the use of force and the protection of civilians, while respecting legitimate limits on the protection of sensitive security information. It also affirms that the public’s right to access information concerning decisions that affect their lives and security is consistent with the principles set out in Article (19) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, within its legal scope and subject to the legitimate restrictions provided therein.
Fourth: Independent Investigation, Accountability, and Reparation
The Center calls for an independent, effective, and impartial investigation into the airstrikes that resulted in civilian casualties, including identifying the victims, the nature of the sites targeted, the informational basis for selecting the targets, and the extent to which the principles of distinction, proportionality, and feasible precautions were observed. The Center bases its call on Article (2/3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which guarantees the right to an effective remedy when protected rights are violated, and Rule (158) of customary international humanitarian law, which requires the investigation of alleged war crimes and, where appropriate, the prosecution of those responsible.
The Center also calls for remedies, reparation, and appropriate compensation to be provided to victims and their families in accordance with the responsibilities established by the findings of the investigations and the applicable legal rules.
Fifth: Government Responsibility and Independent Oversight Mechanisms
The Center welcomes any formal cooperation initiative aimed at de-escalation and enhancing the security of border communities, including the announced agreement to form a joint security committee between Syria and Jordan. However, it stresses that investigations into civilian casualties must not be limited to internal security assessments, but should be subject to independent and competent mechanisms that ensure the integrity of evidence, procedural transparency, and public access to the main findings. It also calls for independent human rights organizations and professional media outlets to be granted safe access to information and incident sites, enabling documentation and verification of the facts, free from misinformation, incitement, and political polarization.
Sixth: De-escalation and the Use of Peaceful Means
The Center calls on the Syrian and Jordanian governments to cease any unlawful military actions that could endanger civilians, and to refrain from retaliatory or escalatory measures that could expand the scope of violence. It calls for diplomatic, judicial, and law-governed security cooperation to be prioritized, and for clear mechanisms to be adopted to prevent and address border incidents, rather than exchanging accusations without providing verifiable evidence.
The Center for Environmental and Social Development affirms that civilians’ right to life, safety, and human dignity must not be subordinated to political considerations or security calculations between states. It also affirms that transparency and accountability are not obstacles to national security, but an essential condition for building trust between governments and communities and ensuring that counterterrorism measures comply with the rule of law and human rights. The security of Jordan, the sovereignty of Syria, and the protection of civilians in both countries are goals that can be achieved together by respecting international law, fostering institutional cooperation, conducting independent investigations into potential violations, and responsibly disclosing agreements and decisions that affect people’s lives and security.
There can be no lasting peace without justice, no genuine security without respect for civilians’ lives, and no effective accountability without truth and transparency.
Center for Environmental and Social Development (CESD)
New York – United States of America

